All
prices are in German marks unless otherwise noted.
At time of show report, 1 U.S. dollar is worth approximately 2.1 German marks.
Pioneer's room was chosen not so much for its exceptional sound
(although it was quite good overall), but rather for the effective presentation in demoing
various audio sources. Pioneer used their DV-AX10 "universal" digital player
(which can play SACD, DVD-A, DVD-V, CD, CD-R and CD-RW) as well as high-end turntable. It
was an opportunity for consumers to hear the format and hear how each compared. The
speakers used were all Isophon Europas -- a brand we are not familiar with. The demo was
conducted by Pioneer's Thomas Hintze.
First up was a two-channel
comparison between CD and SACD. The difference was quite easy to discern. Doug Schneider
thought the CD sounded "stunted" and "slightly hard" in comparison to
the effortless sound of SACD. Jeff Fritz thought that the SACD had "better
upper-midrange and high-frequency extension." It was also not hard to hear that SACD
has increased resolution.
Following that, the comparison
between vinyl, CD and DVD-A was made using Carmina Burana. Surprisingly, both
Doug and Jeff thought that the CD sounded better than the vinyl. The DVD-A presentation of
this music wasn't quite an "apples-to-apples" comparison though. Pioneer chose
to present it in multichannel format, which resulted in vastly increased spaciousness with
far great depth. Output levels seemed to be higher too. What we would have like to have
heard was a two-channel comparison of DVD-A first.
After the audio, Mr. Hintze
demonstrated a DVD-V with a live, on-screen presentation of an African recording artist
with sound in Dolby's AC-3 format. The sound was good, not up to the standard of DVD-A
(except here again we weren't able to compare exact cuts of music), but it did effectively
demonstrate that well-recorded multichannel music can add a vast sense of spaciousness and
involvement. Overall, this was not necessarily an ideal presentation, but it was the best
and most comprehensive we've heard and seen so far.
|